Checking in on the Heisman Trophy

A couple of polls to chew over:

From HeismanPundit.com, which surveys a few voters every week:
  1. Mark Ingram, Alabama

  2. Jimmy Clausen, Notre Dame

  3. Colt McCoy, Texas

  4. Tim Tebow, Florida

  5. Ndamukong Suh, Nebraska

And from the ESPN crew:

  1. Ingram

  2. Clausen

  3. Tebow

  4. McCoy

  5. Kellen Moore, Boise State

That brings us to today's just-for-the-sake-of-argument posting.

The SEC title game is December 5. The Heisman is awarded a week later.

Let's say Florida and Alabama play for the championship. If the Heisman is hanging in the balance, and given the quality of the defenses, who would be more likely to put on a show-stopping performance, Ingram or Tebow?

I say Tebow, but only because what happens with Ingram very much depends on how well Tide QB Greg McElroy is playing that day.

 What say you?

-- RTR